Barnet entered October in 9th place, five matches unbeaten and two wins on the spin. Giuliano Grazioli had gone on loan to Ryman Premier League side, AFC Wimbledon and James Cole went on loan to Wingate and Finchley.
The Bees were looking good after a difficult start, the defence - Devera, Yakubu, Burton and Gillet - looked solid, the central midfield pairing of Bishop and Wright was gelling well and the midfield was not being overrun as had happened in the previous season. Jason Puncheon was in great form, attracting a lot of scouts and Adam Birchall was beginning to run into form after a rather flat start. Rather surprisingly, Liam Hatch, who almost went to Cambridge United in the summer, had not started a game yet, though he had made 7 substitute appearances.
Hatch was again on the bench for the visit of highly fancied, Wycombe who went 1-0 up in the first half. Barnet were giving a rather tired performance, until Hatch came on as a second half substitute and livened up the Bees' performance, firing home a fine Adam Birchall cross to put the scores level and then, Puncheon scored a late winner to make it 3 wins in 3 and 6 matches unbeaten.
The following Saturday saw the Bees travel to
Barnet went into the home match with bottom club,
Nevertheless, the draw had extended Barnet's unbeaten run to 8 matches and the following Saturday, they made it 9 with a fine 2-0 win at struggling Wrexham, both goals coming from Liam Hatch making his first start of the season and now with 4 goals to his name. Jason Norville had made way for Hatch.
The last game of the month saw one of the best games of the season as Accrington Stanley came to Underhill, Barnet going into the match in 5th place. After going a goal down, a wonderful Liam Hatch goal and a first Barnet goal for Sagi Burton looked to have won the game for Barnet, but a Lee Harrison blunder allowed
The following Saturday, Barnet travelled to Bury on the back of a 10 match unbeaten run but crashed back down to earth losing 3-0. It was to be the beginning of a slump in Barnet's league form, though the following Tuesday, Barnet gave a fine performance at home to Notts County, but for the third home game in a row a match that should have been won ended up as a draw. A stunning Jason Puncheon goal put the Bees ahead, but a second half clanger by Lee Harrison meant that Barnet had thrown away 6 points in the last 3 matches. The match saw the return after injury of Michael Leary.
However, Barnet went into the 1st round FA Cup match at home to
Barnet league form continued to slump though as a late goal at
MK Dons, Darlington and Rotherham were in the 3 automatic promotion places, while only 2 points separated the bottom 5 clubs; Wrexham, Lincoln, Grimsby, Dagenham & Redbridge and Mansfield. The Bees needed to get back to winning ways and reverse their recent slump. Nobody wanted to get caught up in the relegation struggle.