| Date | H/A | Competition | Result | Scorers | Attendance | Notes | ||
| Accrington Stanley | ||||||||
| 06/09/2003 | H | Nationwide Conference | 0-0 | 1621 | ||||
| 29/11/2003 | A | Nationwide Conference | 0-2 | 1120 | ||||
| 20/11/2004 | H | Nationwide Conference | 3-0 | King | 1990 | |||
| Graham | ||||||||
| Hatch | ||||||||
| 19/02/2005 | A | Nationwide Conference | 1 4 | Grazioli | 1841 | |||
| 12/08/2006 | A | Coca Cola League Two | 1 2 | King | 1639 | |||
| 10/02/2007 | H | Coca Cola League Two | 1 2 | Birchall | 2041 | |||
| 27/10/2007 | H | Coca Cola League Two | 2 2 | Hatch | 2178 | |||
| Burton | ||||||||
| 19/04/2008 | A | Coca Cola League Two | 2-0 | Bishop | 1288 | |||
| Leary | ||||||||
| 04/10/2008 | H | Coca Cola League Two | 2 1 | O'Flynn | 1899 | |||
| Yakubu | ||||||||
| 24/01/2009 | A | Coca Cola League Two | 1 1 | Furlong | 1056 | |||
| 28/11/2009 | A | FA Cup 2nd Round | 2 2 | Yakubu | 1501 | |||
| O'Flynn (pen) | ||||||||
| 08/12/2009 | H | FA Cup 2nd Round (replay) | 0-1 | 1288 | ||||
| 13/03/2010 | H | Coca Cola League Two | 1 2 | O'Flynn (pen) | 1559 | |||
| 27/04/2010 | A | Coca Cola League Two | 0-1 | 1268 | ||||
| 11/12/2010 | H | Coca Cola League Two | 2-0 | McLeod (2) | 2250 | |||
| 30/04/2011 | A | Coca Cola League Two | 1 3 | Marshall | 2764 | |||
| 03/09/2011 | H | Npower League Two | 0-0 | 2380 | ||||
| 14/01/2012 | A | Npower League Two | 3-0 | Holmes | 1652 | |||
| Hughes | ||||||||
| Deering | ||||||||
| 16/11/2012 | H | Npower League Two | 1 1 | Byrne (pen) | 2238 | |||
| 16/03/2013 | A | Npower League Two | 2 3 | Johnson | 1559 | |||
| Jenkins | ||||||||