Anthony Charles joined Barnet from Farnborough in January 2005 for £12,000 and helped the Bees win the Nationwide Conference title at the end of that season. He made 60 league starts, plus another 6 as a substitute before moving to Aldershot, initially on loan in 2007. He gained a second Conference winner medal, this time with Aldershot, in 2008. He is now Aldershot captain.
Louie Soares joined Barnet in the summer of 2005 after impressing in trial games. He was previously with Reading. He made 14 starts, plus another 6 appearances as a substitute, scoring 1 goal, away at Shrewsbury, before moving to Aldershot in 2006. He helped the Shots win the Conference in 2008. He now plays for Southend United..
Mikhael Jaimez-Ruiz joined Barnet in 2006 but failed to make a first team appearance and moved to Aldershot in 2007.
Ahmed Deen joined Aldershot in 2005 from Peterborough and made 11 Conference appearances for the Shots. He joined Barnet in the summer of 2009 from Macclesfield Town and made 16 league appearances for the Bees, scoring 1 goal before being released at the end of the season. He now plays for Hayes & Yeading.
Other players to have played for both clubs include Andy Pape, Richard Dunwell, Turkan Mustafa, Greg Heald and John Collis.